Find an Agent

Looking for a policy? Enter your zip code to get started!

Invalid zip code
Why Lancaster Mutual?
Who we are

Lancaster Mutual is here to offer hard-working people affordable, high quality Personal, Farm and Commercial insurance coverage through local independent agents, to help more people protect the things that matter most to them.

Our goal is to be the best, most reliable choice for our “community of members” who count on Lancaster Mutual’s competitive options, stable pricing, and excellent customer service.

How we support members

Today, insurance options are limited for certain types of residential, rental, business, and farm properties. As a result, too many people are forced to choose policies based on what they can afford, rather than what they truly need. Lancaster Mutual was created to help customers choose better-quality options they can trust and afford.

By being friendly, fair, and responsive, Lancaster Mutual Insurance Company enables more people to better protect the things that matter most to them.

What we are known for
Goodville Group
We offer an accessible and versatile range of coverages in home, business, and farm lines.
Goodville Group
Our agents are carefully chosen in order to bring the highest quality service to our members.
Goodville Group
We’re here to serve our members and help protect what matters most to them.
Let Us Help!

We look forward to our opportunities to protect you

Goodville Group